Quarter Life Crisis

The world according to Sven-S. Porst

« DrawingMainPoints of Failure »

Copy Controlled

237 words on

So I accidentally bought a CD with copy ‘protection’. The problem with it was that I didn’t actually notice that immediately because it’s not exactly printed in a gigantic size across the cover and the CD could be used and ripped by iTunes just fine. Only much later I discovered that there’s this strange note on the CD and – upon double checking on the computer – noticed that a second partition with a crippled playback application is on the CD.

And while I still fear that its intrinsic brokenness will render the CD unplayable in the future, what exactly is the point of this? Who’d want to use that crappy playback program they include when they have a perfectly good and user-friendly copy of iTunes installed? Heck, their playback program seems to be based on Microsoft technology. And ever since Internet Explorer for Mac was retired, having a Microsoft (code) free computer seemed not only like a good but also like a realistic idea.

Record companies need to go to hell urgently! And they need to make sure to take their technology and marketing people with them. The bands who are with those clueless companies need to make sure they watch their own output as well. With the hassle and insults that come with the ‘copy controlled’ idea, respect is lost quickly. And the good old world of file sharing networks starts looking attractive once more.

Kooks' CD that is copy controlled, playing with its own software player while being ripped by iTunes

May 10, 2006, 8:17

Tagged as music.


Comment by Hauke Fath: User icon

I’ve had quite a few of these Un-CDs, as the German computer magazine c’t likes to call them, in the past. All of them could be ripped just fine to AIFF as well as mp3 on a Mac. And like with software copy protection schemes, you are better off with a cracked copy than with the original, which may or may not play on your 15 year-old CD player.

The only point that I can see in those Un-CDs is that they slowly erode the CompactDisk standard.

May 10, 2006, 14:15

Comment by d.w.: User icon

Be careful even running those horrible “player” applications from these miserable “un-CDs” — the screen full of legalese you click through when you run it often contains language that implies that, by running the application, you’re allowing them to install all manner of garbage on your computer.

May 13, 2006, 10:18

Add your comment

« DrawingMainPoints of Failure »

Comments on




This page

Out & About

pinboard Links